How do we decide what are the valid tasks we should engage in at the Lord’s Supper? I suppose there are several bases. There is tradition handed down from somewhere, there is pragmatism connected to what may be easiest, there is indifference because we don’t think it matters very much, and there is individualism (it is all about Jesus and me and let’s ignore the communal aspect).
After I was converted I became a member in a congregation that held the Lord’s Supper frequently. The services in which the Supper occurred could be quite different from one another. There was not a fixed order of what should precede or what should follow the actual Supper. Yet one detail did not change, which was that thanksgiving for the bread was given separately from thanksgiving for the wine. By separate, I don’t mean that there was a large period of time between the two prayers. Usually, they followed one another, and often the same person on the day would give thanks for both.
I am now in a denomination in which one thanksgiving is made for the bread and wine, which are then passed round the congregation rather quickly, often at such a rate that an individual does not have the time to swallow the bread before he or she is presented with the cup of wine.
This is the way it is done in several denominations whose services I have attended. Others have devised another method, which is to distribute the bread, but ask the believers to refrain from eating it until everyone has a piece, and then eat together, which means that they are waiting for a signal when to eat. When it comes to the wine, individual cups are given out and when ready each takes their cup at the same time. While it is possible to imagine the disciples at the first Lord’s Supper holding on to the bread until each had a piece, it is not possible to do so with the wine because Jesus made them drink in rotation from the same cup. So while this method may look as if it is depicting unity, it is not what Jesus asked his followers to do.
Which method is closest to what Jesus did? We know from the Gospel accounts that he gave thanks separately for the bread and for the wine. What method did Paul say should be done in Corinth, and his comments in 1 Corinthians 11 are the only detailed account of an occasion of the Lord’s Supper found in the epistles? His description indicates that separate prayers of thanksgiving should be done in Corinth. There were reasons to be concerned with what was occurring in the church in Corinth at the Lord’s Supper, but Paul did not suggest as part of his correction that they should have one prayer instead of two.
What benefit is there in having the elements given with separate prayers? It looks to me that it affects time for reflection separately on the perfect body of Jesus and on the death he became subject to. Having the bread passed round by itself enables the congregation together to reflect, under the Spirit’s leading, on what his holy humanity was like. Then when the congregation takes the cup, they under the Spirit’s guidance can focus together on the Saviour’s self-giving on the cross. In this way, they can have communion with one another and with Jesus as well.
Of course, it is possible for individuals to think about the beauty and sacrifice of Jesus when one prayer of thanksgiving is made. Yet, as we are often told, time is of the essence. What can be said about the essential time we spend at the Lord’s Supper? After all, it is not just believers meeting with one another, it is also believers spending time with Jesus. And if he wanted the first disciples, as well as the disciples in Corinth, to have a specific way of taking the bread and the wine, we should ask if that is what he wants us to do. I suspect spiritual blessings are connected to his method that we can miss out on even by only a slight change.
No comments:
Post a Comment