Robert Letham, in this volume, discusses important aspects of the second person of the Trinity. The book is the second of a trilogy on the Trinity, one on the Holy Spirit having already been published. This volume has a foreword by Ian Hamilton and several endorsements by well-known theologians.
As I read the volume, I discovered that the author was a well-informed guide taking me on a journey through the Christian era and stopping at crucial moments to introduce me to characters who have proposed how the person of the eternal Son should be understood, spending time with some more than with others.
To begin with, the author points out that the names Father, Son and Holy Spirit are what God is in himself and that each of the relations are eternal. To appreciate those relations, we need the teachings of the Bible and the opinions of the church, made by councils and stated in creeds, on those teachings, especially when they were misunderstood or reinterpreted.
In the early centuries of church history, two heresies affected the church’s understanding of the Trinity: modalism which denied the personal distinctions in the Trinity, and subordinationism which advocated that the Son and the Holy Spirit were not as divine as the Father. While modalism was dealt with shortly after the middle of the third century, subordinationism led to Arianism in the fourth century, which argued that the Son and the Holy Spirit were not co-eternal with the Father. It was difficult, if not impossible, to counter the heresies by using only biblical terminology and eventually the term homoousios was used to state the one substance of the Godhead and hypostases for the three divine persons.
In chapter 2, entitled ‘Before the Beginning’, the author considers the relationship between eternity and time, and between God and the creation, before discussing the decisions God made about an elect church, composed of elect individuals, and the prior election of Christ, with what was decided about him affecting what was decided about them. This also means accepting that the creation of Adam in God’s image had in view the later coming of Christ, the full image of God.
The author then discusses various attempts to understand those divine decisions. He does not accept the ways some have explained the covenant of redemption, pointing out that they have omitted the Holy Spirit from the agreement and have used human methods of bargaining to describe the roles of the Father and the Son. He notes that although some are more careful in how they describe the covenant, yet since the notion of a covenant requires more than one party, he argues that it would be better to call the decisions as ‘the Trinitarian counsel of redemption’ as this retains the indivisibility of the Trinity. He also mentions Barth’s understanding of the Son as the electing God and elected man. Attention is also given to a debate as to whether divine election affected or even caused the Trinity.
Chapter 3 focuses on the incarnation when the Son of God became man by assuming a human nature through a virginal conception brought about by the Holy Spirit. While the conception was unique, the gestation and birth were normal. He became flesh without ceasing to be the divine Son. The flesh that he became was weak and dependent, yet through it the Son revealed God. Some heretics, despite the clear evidence of the Gospel records, argued that the flesh he took was not real. As a man he depended on the Holy Spirit, including during his work on the cross.
Chapter 4 discusses faulty teachings about the two natures in the incarnate Son (by Apollinaris, Nestorius and Eutyches) before explaining the orthodox response led by Cyril of Alexandria and affirmed at the Councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon; and Chapter 5 summarises terms such as theotokos, anhypostatos, enhypostatos, and others to prepare readers for further discussions down the line.
Many assume that Chalcedon brought clarity and closure to the debates about the person of Christ, but the assumption ignores what took place, as chapter 6 describes. In the chapter we meet Monophysites and Dyophysites and some of their prominent theologians, as well as reading about the Council of Constantinople II (553). Issues connected to Nestorianism lingered on, as did attempts to ensure that Chalcedon was interpreted in a manner that supported more assertively the teachings of Cyril, including by the emperor Justinian who was also a credible theologian.
In chapter 7, we reach the seventh century during which the important contribution of Maximus the Confessor helped the church to affirm at Constantinople III that Christ as a person has two natures (divine and human) and two wills (divine and human) and how a denial of the doctrine caused complex misunderstandings of his person. In reading this chapter I was glad to use the glossary at the end of the volume. It was salutary to discover that some well-known names in contemporary evangelicalism advocate some of those misunderstandings. Maximus also contributed to the meaning of human and cosmic glorification and of how the incarnation of the Son leads to that end.
Chapter 8 focuses on two contributions. One is by John of Damascus in the eighth century on the meaning of perichoresis or mutual indwelling regarding the two natures of Christ and the other is by Thomas Aquinas from the thirteenth century, and on, among other matters, what he said on the appropriateness of the Son rather than the Father or the Holy Spirit becoming incarnate.
Chapter 9 brings the reader to the Reformation period. It is well-known that Christological understanding affected how leading Reformers explained the presence of Christ at the Lord’s Supper. Although they agreed that the Son had a divine nature and a human nature, they did not agree with how they functioned in the one person, with elements of Nestorianism not far away at times. Debate occurred on Calvin’s teaching on the Son asautotheos. The meaning of the eternal generation of the Son was explored. Discussions about how the humanity of Christ is life-giving occurred. And was understanding the relationship between Jesus and the Holy Spirit advanced or not by the teaching of John Owen.
In Chapter 10, under Post-Enlightenment Questions, the author considers two ideas that arose in the nineteenth century. First, he explains how nineteenth-century advocates of the kenosis theory understood Christ’s self-emptying and how others opposed them, and how Monotheletism influences some current advocates of the theory. Second, he assesses the question of Christ’s peccability and then focuses on the ideas of those advocating that Christ had a fallen human nature.
Chapter 11 is the chapter that considers the work of Christ in more detail. It is important to see that he is our salvation, that it is connected to his incarnation, to his life and death, and to his resurrection and ascension. His dereliction on the cross did not cause any disruption in the life of the Trinity. He became incarnate so that he could make atonement for sinners, and he made atonement for them so that they could experience deification or glorification ultimately amid cosmic renewal.
The volume has two appendixes, each concerned about recent interpretations of biblical texts about Christ. The first considers the claim made by David Garner in his book Sons in the Son that Christ was adopted at his resurrection and finds Garner’s teaching defective for several reasons. The second assesses negatively the claim of David Moffitt in his book, Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews, in which he argues that the atonement was not made on the cross but when Jesus presented his blood in heaven after his resurrection.
There is much more to the book than the matters highlighted above. Unlike literal journeys where the rate of travel is not in the control of the passenger, readers can read at their own speed and even reverse at numerous times to reconsider what has been said previously, and through doing so discover important details that they missed on the earlier discussion.
The travel through time observing the various contributions, considerations, corrections and challenges to understanding the person of the eternal Son was informative, intriguing and inspiring. It was a reminder of how great he is, and of the importance of being correct in our appreciation. The author is able to guide us through ideas about Jesus that we may not have known before, but which our predecessors discussed in detail. Sometimes, on the journey, I initially thought that we had been there before, only to find that old, discarded ideas have the tendency to reappear in new ways.
Virtually every day I find my mind going to the catechism answer I learned as a child: ‘The only Redeemer of God’s elect is the Lord Jesus Christ, who, being the eternal Son of God, became man, and so was, and continueth to be, God and man in two distinct natures, and one person, for ever.’ Letham’s book enables us to consider deeply who the eternal Son is.
Published in Foundations Journal, Autumn 2026
No comments:
Post a Comment